Two New Columns: Chicago Sun-Times Bashes Dads, DV Offender Registry Will Harm Innocent Men

April 17, 2007

 
New Column: Texas Bill to Create Domestic Violence Offender Registry Will Harm Innocent Men

My new co-authored column, "Texas bill to create domestic violence offender registry will harm innocent men" (Austin American-Statesman, 4/11/07), asserts that Texas HB 3958, which will be heard in the Corrections Committee of the Texas House this week, will ensnare and punish many innocent men. This is in part because of the problems with the way Texas law enforcement and the judicial system handle domestic violence.

Texas bill to create domestic violence offender registry will harm innocent men
By Mike McCormick and Glenn Sacks
Austin American-Statesman, 4/11/07

House Bill 3958, sponsored by Rep. Joaquin Castro (D-San Antonio), will set up a domestic violence offender registry similar to the Texas Sex Offender Registry. Castro is correct to identify domestic violence as an important issue; however, there are serious problems with the way law enforcement and the judicial system handle domestic violence. These problems will cause many innocent men to be ensnared by this bill.

HB 3958 would set up a central database containing information on anyone who has been convicted or "received a grant of deferred adjudication" for a family violence offense on three occasions. The three conviction requirement is defensible, but the inclusion of deferred adjudications -- which are analogous to plea bargains -- is a major problem.

Like many states, Texas has adopted aggressive arrest procedures on domestic violence calls. While politically popular, many of the architects of these types of policies are increasingly concerned that they have led to widespread

Reach 5 Million
Readers Every Year
Are you looking for an affordable way to reach 5 million readers a year with your business, organization or message? My weekly E-Newsletter has over 50,000 subscribers, and is by far the world's largest regularly distributed E-newsletter devoted to family law reform, fatherhood and fathers' issues. My blog and my websites GlennSacks.com and HisSide.com are on pace to receive 3 million visits this year.
 
Contact us for more information.
 

Do You Support Our Work? If You Do, Donate Here

 

Need Help with Family Law or Child Support? Ask Glenn

abuses. For example, Greg Schmidt, who created the Seattle Police Department's domestic violence investigation unit in 1994, says that police officers are often encouraged to make arrests "in petty incidents, often where the abuse is mutual or it is unclear who the aggressor was." Moreover, Schmidt has concluded that the policies and the political climate that surround them pressures officers to see men and only men as the offenders, even though research shows that women comprise a significant minority of those who commit domestic violence.

Former Dallas Police Department patrol officer Paul Stuckle, now a criminal defense attorney in Plano, believes that these policies often lead Texas police to make arrests based only on the alleged victim's statements, and that officers often fail to complete a fair and thorough investigation.

The highly publicized case of former major league baseball player Scott Erickson has come to symbolize the problems with aggressive domestic violence arrest policies. Erickson called the police during an altercation with his girlfriend in July of 2002. According to The Associated Press, the Baltimore, Maryland police concluded that Erickson's girlfriend Lisa Ortiz: initiated the fight by hurling objects; decided to come back twice after Erickson carried her out of the apartment; repeatedly kicked the apartment door; caused Erickson two minor injuries, one of them to his pitching arm; and herself suffered no injuries. Nonetheless, the police arrested Erickson. Afterwards Ortiz publicly stated that Erickson, who did not pursue her either time after carrying her out, "has never been physically abusive toward me."

Erickson and his legal team did manage to get the charges dropped, but most men aren't so fortunate. Many Texas District Attorneys follow "No Drop" policies in domestic violence cases, pursuing marginal cases which ordinarily would be dropped for lack of evidence. Without a strong criminal case, prosecutors often try to intimidate defendants into accepting seemingly harmless deferred adjudications. Most men in these situations lack the money and resources to wage a long legal battle, and accept deferred adjudications, often without realizing that they cannot be expunged.

Inclusion on the domestic violence offender registry will be ruinous to some men's careers and reputations. The list will contain the person's name, photograph, date of birth, last known address, physical description and their offenses. Many of the men who will be placed on the registry are noncustodial fathers with child support obligations, and the registry will make it much more difficult for them to get and keep jobs.

In addition, the list would be applied retroactively. Men who agreed to deferred adjudications in previous years did so without knowing that their decision not to fight their case in criminal court would place them on a domestic violence offender registry for life.

The bill's requirement of three cases does provide a safeguard of sorts. Yet once the registry is created, it is very possible that future legislation will lower the requirements for inclusion to two or even one case. It is also possible that men with domestic violence restraining orders will be placed on the list, even though these restraining orders are granted to almost all who apply, with little judicial review. The bill may also be amended to require the state to pass out flyers with all the man's information on it to every household within a mile of his house, just as is done with the Texas Sex Offender
Registry.

Many deferred adjudications are not fair findings of wrongdoing, and should not be treated as such. HB 3958 will harm many innocent men.

To discuss this issue on my blog, click here.


New Column: Responding to Chicago Sun-Times' Dad-Bashing

My new co-authored column, Child Support System Ignores Dads' Economic Reality (Chicago Sun-Times, 4/14/07), responds to the Sun-Times' father-bashing news story State's deadbeat dads owe $3 billion--Deadbeat parents owe $3 billion in Illinois alone, $100 billion nationwide. When parents refuse to honor child support, their kids pay. And so do you (4/8/07).

The story was on the front page of the Sun-Times with the huge headline "The 12 Worst Dads in Illinois." I do commend the Sun-Times for its willingness to publish such criticism.

To write a Letter to the Editor of the Chicago Sun-Times regarding Child support system ignores dads' economic reality (4/14/07), write to letters@suntimes.com.

In the column family law attorney Jeffery M. Leving and I wrote:

"The Sun-Times tells us that 'divorce lawyers joke that high-earning husbands come down with 'AIDS' after a divorce--'Acquired Income Deficiency Syndrome.'' Yet if one tries thinking of divorced fathers as people instead of as villains, it's not hard to see why some dads earn less money after a divorce.

"Divorce is a psychologically shattering event for fathers, usually more so than for mothers. Fathers--not mothers--are often cut off from their children. Many suffer from depression. A divorced father is ten times more likely to commit suicide than a divorced mother, and three times more likely to commit suicide than a married father.

"The vast majority of divorces are initiated by women, not by men. Research shows that most of these do not involve a serious transgression by the men, such as violence or adultery, but instead because the women feel unappreciated or emotionally unfulfilled. From a man's perspective, this often means that his wife: ended the marriage against his will; took his children out of his everyday life; and harmed his kids by breaking up the stable, two-parent home they once enjoyed. Then she demanded that he dramatically lower his standard of living in order to finance her decision. It's not hard to see why men who once worked hard to support their families may be too disheartened to make the same sacrifices under these new conditions.

"Mothers often violate fathers' already meager visitation rights, and sometimes alienate their children from them. Some mothers move far away in order to frustrate fathers' contact with their children, while others make spurious accusations of abuse. Fathers are sometimes financially ruined by divorce--legal bills are huge, and they are often compelled by courts to pay their ex-wives' legal costs, too.

"Given the myriad injustices and problems fathers face when dealing with the family law system, it isn't surprising that there are divorced fathers who don't pay their child support. What's surprising is that so many do."

Read the full column here.

To discuss this issue on my blog, click here.


Is This Man Really the 'Second Worst Dad in Illinois'?

Background: My new co-authored column, Child Support System Ignores Dads' Economic Reality (Chicago Sun-Times, 4/14/07), responds to the Sun-Times' father-bashing news story State's deadbeat dads owe $3 billion--Deadbeat parents owe $3 billion in Illinois alone, $100 billion nationwide. When parents refuse to honor child support, their kids pay. And so do you (4/8/07).

The story was on the front page of the Sun-Times with the huge headline "The 12 Worst Dads in Illinois." I do commend the Sun-Times for its willingness to publish such criticism; however, I question some of their priorities.

Mark Saban (pictured, with his daughters) was singled out by the Sun-Times for criticism. Yet the article also backhandedly informs us that Saban:

1) Visits his kids regularly

2) Has paid some child support

3) Puts forth a plausible case that after his business failed he lost the ability to pay the support that was demanded of him, thus becoming a "deadbeat dad." (I don't know if Saban is being completely truthful about his economic situation, but from the article it certainly is at least debatable.)

Despite this, the Sun-Times lists him on its front page (with a picture) as the "Second Worst Dad in Illinois." Only one who views a father as an ATM machine and nothing more could agree with this characterization.

To discuss this issue on my blog, click here.
 

Erectile Dysfunction? Hair Loss? The Men's Renaissance Health Centers Can Help
The Men's Renaissance Health Centers are a specialty medical facility dedicated to the treatment of Men's Sexual Health, Hair Transplantation, and Cosmetic Dermatology. MRHC features the latest "Star Lux" Laser technology for Facial Rejuvenation and Hair Removal. Call (866) 398-6086 for more info., and mention Glenn Sacks to receive special rates.

Erectile Dysfunction? Confidential Consultations, Noninvasive Solutions
Men's Renaissance Heath Center specializes in confidential consultations on Erectile Dysfunction, Premature Ejaculation and Sexual Potency. Unlike other clinics that focus the patient on one invasive procedure featuring constant injections, MRHC starts with a thorough exam by a medical doctor and seeks to find the most appropriate and least invasive solution to the problem. Offering FDA approved medications and devices, the MRHC makes the process of recovering youthful performance levels comfortable and rapid. Call (866) 398-6086 for more info., and mention Glenn Sacks to receive special rates.

Hair Loss? Follicular Unit Transplantation is the New Gold Standard
Follicular Unit Transplantation is the newest technique of permanent surgical hair restoration. With FUT, hair is transplanted from the permanent zone in the back of the scalp into balding areas, using only one's own naturally occurring, individual follicular units. This unique procedure provides what we all want: hair that looks natural throughout, no matter what we do or which way the wind blows. Most importantly, transplanted hair will continue to grow for the rest of the patient's life. Call (866) 398-6086 for more info., and mention Glenn Sacks to receive special rates.


I Will Be Participating in the New 'Being a Better Dad' Teleseminar Series--First Teleseminar is April 19

I am partnering with Parental Alienation expert J. Michael Bone, Ph.D., John Curtis, Ph.D., author of The Business of Love, and Debby Hirschhorn Ph.D., author of The Secret Marriage Killer: Eradicating Verbal and Emotional Abuse, in the new 'Being a Better Dad' Teleseminar series.

The seminar is a convenient way for men to learn vital information or gain new skills on being a better dad. Fathers can attend training from the privacy of their own homes via telephone.

A Certificate of Attendance will be awarded to fathers who complete all 4 hours of "Being a Better Dad," and can be used to help show judges, child custody evaluators, mediators, etc., your commitment to co-parenting after divorce or separation, and to being the best dad you can be.

The first Teleseminar is Thursday April 19 (9 p.m. EDT / 6 p.m. PDT)--to sign up, go to www.beingabetterdad.com.

I love being a dad, but there are times when it can be trying, and parenting during divorce or separation must be 10 or 100 times more difficult. The Being a Better Dad seminars are designed to help. The Being a Better Dad seminars cover:

- The national perspective on the most significant parenting and men's issues of 2007
- How a father can respond to Parental Alienation (where one parent tries to turn a child against the other parent)
- Stopping verbal abuse in marital or post-marital conflict along with winning strategies to raising healthier children
- A new approach to healthy intimate relationships based on business strategies that will actually work in the 21st century especially among dual-income couples

The Teleseminar's presenters are:

J. Michael Bone, Ph.D. is a national expert on Parental Alienation and high conflict divorce. He has been an evaluator, expert witness and educator on Parental Alienation in courts throughout the United States.

Debby Hirschhorn Ph.D. is a marriage and family therapist and the author of The Secret Marriage Killer: Eradicating Verbal and Emotional Abuse and How to Get Your Kids to WANT to Do What YOU Want Them to.

John Curtis, Ph.D. is the author of The Business of Love: 9 Best Practices for Improving the Bottom Line of Your Relationship, a unique book which details a step-by-step approach to apply proven business strategies to a marriage. Curtis and The Business of Love have been covered by the Today Show, the New York Times, Bloomberg Financial and numerous others.

Glenn Sacks is a fathers' advocate and columnist, commentator, blogger and talk show host. His columns appear regularly in US newspapers, he has made hundreds of radio and TV appearances, and is often quoted on fathers' issues in newspapers and magazines.

The first Teleseminar is Thursday April 19 (9 p.m. EDT / 6 p.m. PDT)--to sign up, go to www.beingabetterdad.com.

To discuss this issue on my blog, click here.


Does This Look Like a Harmless Escapade to You?

I've complained in print several times about the kid gloves treatment former astronaut Lisa Nowak has been receiving from the media, NASA, and prosecutors, and pointed out that this preferential treatment is common for female offenders.

Whereas one would think that a Naval officer who tried to kidnap and murder another serviceman would be court-martialed, Nowak has instead been reassigned to Naval Air Station Corpus Christi to serve as a training officer. Whereas Nowak should have been charged with attempted murder, she is being charged with attempted kidnapping instead.

Worst of all, whereas the media should have condemned Nowak in the strongest terms, much of the media made excuses for her and portrayed her as a sympathetic victim, depicting her actions merely as a "nutty" or "bizarre" escapade. A few examples, drawn from my co-authored column Scott Peterson in a Space Suit (Philadelphia Daily News, 2/26/07):

1) CBS commentator Harry Smith expressed sympathy for this "poor" woman for "falling in love" and then "crash-landing."

 2) Fox News commentator Steve Doocy opined that "love makes you do weird things," and claimed that prosecutors were being too hard on Nowak.

3) MSNBC described Nowak as a stressed out "super mom" who "snapped."

4) A psychologist on MSNBC sympathetically explained that the would-be murderess acted because she was "experiencing the fear of abandonment" that was "so terrifying" that she had to "secure the love object and eliminate the threat."

5) A reporter for a major newspaper described the murder attempt as Nowak's effort to "share with someone else a bit of the pain swelling inside."

6) One major newspaper sadly lamented Nowak's "meltdown," a term usually used to describe a performer's onstage temper tantrum, not an apparent murder attempt.

7) One commentator labeled Nowak an "unfortunate" individual who "has been the subject of relentless news coverage...[and] hounded and beleaguered by the press," an unusually sympathetic description of the media attention people bring upon themselves when they try to kill someone.

Pictured above are the knife and sledgehammer that Nowak was carrying with her when she attacked romantic rival Colleen Shipman--do they look like the tools of a harmless escapade to you?

To read more and to discuss this issue on my blog, click here.

The American Coalition for Fathers and Children
The American Coalition for Fathers and Children is dedicated to creating a family law system which promotes equal rights for all parties affected by divorce. Contact the ACFC at 1-800-978-3237 or visit them on the web at www.acfc.org.

Parental-Alienation-Awareness.com Workshop 2007
Parental-Alienation-Awareness.com will be sponsoring a conference on Parental Alienation in Palmetto, Florida on April 14-15, 2007. This conference will cover the legal, psychological, social, and familial aspects of parental alienation, child abduction, child abuse, and custody and divorce issues. Speakers will include Dr. Stephen Ceci, PhD, author of Jeopardy in the Courtroom, Harvey Shapiro, a retired law enforcement official who is an expert on false sexual allegations, Randy Rand, Ed. D., and numerous others. To learn more, click here.

Parental-Alienation-Awareness.com does good work--it is they who have made the remarkable achievement of getting the Governors of Nevada, Maine and Iowa to proclaim April 25 as Parental Alienation Awareness Day. To contact Parental-Alienation-Awareness.com, write to Robin Denison at robin@parental-alienation-awareness.com.

Good News, Bad News on the Fight Against Parental Alienation

First the good news...

Nebraska, Kentucky Governors Proclaim April 25th Parental Alienation Awareness Day

Background: I've been surprised and impressed with the progress that the Parental Alienation Awareness Organization has made in gaining recognition of April 25 as "Parental Alienation Awareness Day."

Last year they got the Governors of three states to officially recognize April 25 as PAAD, and are working on more. 

As I've noted on many occasions (click here and here), Parental Alienation is a vile scourge, and I fully endorse these activists' efforts. Their latest press release--with the good news that two new states are recognizing PAAD--is below.

Nebraska Governor Dave Heineman and Kentucky Governor Ernie Fletcher Join the Governors of Maine, Iowa, and Nevada in Recognizing and Proclaiming April 25th as Parental Alienation Awareness Day

Parental Alienation Awareness Organization (PAAO) is pleased to announce that Nebraska and Kentucky are among the states that recognize the importance of Parental Alienation awareness. The PAAO is working towards having the behaviors involved in Parental Alienation recognized on a statewide level.

Parental Alienation and Hostile Aggressive Parenting involve a series of behaviors that can effectively alienate a child from a parent. They are often seen in the context of high-conflict divorce or custody cases and are done by a third party, such as a parent or extended family. Such behaviors interfere with the bond between a loving parent and child.

To read more and to discuss this issue on my blog, click here.

And now, the not so good news...

Bill to Make It Harder to Protect Children from Parental Alienation Passes Committee

AB 612, a bill which will make it harder to protect children from Parental Alienation, passed the California Assembly Judiciary Committee last week on an 8-1 vote.

The bill would discourage mental health professionals from issuing findings of Parental Alienation in divorce/custody cases. It would also make it more difficult for target parents to get courts to order psychological evaluations as part of child custody investigations. To learn more about the bill, see my co-authored column AB 612 Will Make It Harder to Protect Children from Parental Alienation (Riverside Press-Enterprise, 4/2/07).

On a positive note, while it's still a bad bill, the worst language from the bill was struck, largely (though not completely) weakening the bill. Originally the bill read:

"Controversial, nonscientific labels, such as parental alienation syndrome, parental alienation, or alienated child, are specifically excluded as allowable diagnoses and for court use."

The Family Law Executive Committee of the California State Bar opposed this language, and Michael Robinson of the California Alliance for Families and Children worked with mental health professionals to get it removed.

To discuss this issue on my blog, click here.

Jeff Leving's New Book--Divorce Wars
Jeffery M. Leving, one of America's most prominent divorce lawyers, has written a new book on how to win any divorce fairly, even when your spouse brings out the heavy artillery. Divorce Wars: A Field Guide to the Winning Tactics, Preemptive Strikes, and Top Maneuvers When Divorce Gets Ugly provides essential advice on everything from picking the right lawyer and devising a winning settlement strategy to getting the most from your day in court and dealing with an ex-spouse. Divorce Wars is available here.

Help, Resources for Dads
The National Fathers' Resource Center is a division of Fathers For Equal Rights, Inc. (FER), located in Dallas, Texas, with offices in both Dallas and Houston. In existence for over three decades, it has services and resources for dads nationwide and is one of the largest and most active fathers' rights organizations in the U.S. www.fathers4kids.org

Get Great Travel Deals and Support Fathers For Equal Rights
Get a great deal on your travel plans and support Fathers For Equal Rights at the same time! Now Fathers For Equal Rights has its own travel website. The site offers flights, lodging, cruises, rental cars and much more, and when you book your travel through this website, Fathers For Equal Rights gets a whopping 40% of the commissions! To learn more, click here.


Do You Have a Post-Divorce Parenting Question? Ask Shared Parenting Expert Warren Farrell

Background: Perhaps the best and most powerful presentation on shared parenting I've ever seen was made by Warren Farrell, author of Father & Child Reunion, at the American Coalition for Fathers and Children's Family Law Reform conference last September. Farrell detailed his research on children of divorce.

Farrell's central findings include: children do best when the time spent with each parent is as close to 50% as practically possible; children of divorce do better with shared parenting than with any other structure, including living with their mother and a step dad; badmouthing behavior which can alienate the children from the other parent is very damaging; and children do best when the divorced parents live close to each other. To watch Farrell's speech at the conference, click here.

Farrell has an excellent new DVD series called The Best Interests of the Child: How to Save Our Child When We Can't Save our Marriage which details his research on fathers and shared parenting--to learn more, click here.

Do you have a post-divorce parenting question? Shared Parenting expert Warren Farrell will answer it on my blog and in my E-Newsletter. Send us your question at Glenn@GlennSacks.com. Please keep your questions at 50 words or less.


Well, at Least It's Accurate...

"In the American family, the mother comes first, then the kids, then the dog, then the cat, and then the father."--Tomas, my Cuban immigrant father-in-law

From Don Wright, political cartoonist for The Palm Beach Post.

To discuss this issue on my blog, click here.

Help for Midwest Fathers
Cordell & Cordell is one of the largest domestic relations firms for men in the Midwest, representing fathers in Missouri, Illinois, Texas, Kansas, Indiana and Georgia. Men who come to Cordell & Cordell know that their interests and the interests of their children will be aggressively championed. www.cordellcordell.com

Civil War - A Father's Guide to Winning Child Custody
Joseph E. Cordell's Civil War - A Father's Guide to Winning Child Custody  gives fathers clear, easy-to-understand tips on how to achieve the best results possible in a divorce. Comprehensive chapters explain every step of the divorce process, the meaning of legal terms, how courts determine custody, and how to maximize chances of victory at every stage. Cordell is the founder of Cordell & Cordell.


Feminist TV Commentator Amanda Platell Gets It Right on IVF Case

Background: Amanda Platell is a feminist British TV commentator who can be seen giving UK Fathers 4 Justice leader Matt O'Connor a hard time here. I criticized her for that, but she recently wrote a very prescient article on the controversial Natallie Evans IVF case. In that case Evans (pictured right), who had cancer, was denied the right to use the frozen embryos fertilized by ex-partner. Platell asks, "A tragedy for Natalie Evans, but what about fathers?"

The court was right to stop Natallie becoming a mother
By Amanda Platell
Daily Mail, 4/11/07

The moment Natallie Evans broke down, having just heard that her embryos would be destroyed and would never become the beloved child she dreamed of, her pain was clear for all to see. But perhaps more clear for those of us who, like Natallie, have also struggled to have a child, who like her have battled through years of disappointment, only one ghastly day to have to accept the truth - that we will never be a mother. I too have known the depths of that darkness, and have some idea of the pain ahead for her: the loitering by Baby Gap, the lingering glances into baby buggies, the bitter-sweet smile at mums at the school gate. If anyone should be her champion, it should be me. But I know that the heartbreak verdict was the right one. The decision not to allow this young woman to use her frozen embryos was truly a terrible tragedy for Natallie. But it was the only decision the courts could come to.

Why? Because had the European Court of Human Rights supported Ms Evans's claim to an inalienable right to motherhood, it would have legislated men out of fatherhood ... and legislated fathers out of families.

In other words, it would have set in law the right of a woman to use a man as nothing more than a means of having a baby - irrespective of the father's wishes or, indeed, the future needs of the child.

The case of Natallie Evans is a tragedy in three parts, starting five years ago when, at just 29, she was diagnosed with ovarian cancer.

She and her partner Howard Johnston began IVF treatment in order that, after her ovaries were removed, she would still be able to have their child. Six of the couple's fertilised embryos were frozen and stored.

Then a year later, tragedy struck again when she and her fiance split up. Mr Johnston wrote to the clinic where the embryos were stored and asked for them to be destroyed.

He was within his rights to do so, since British law sensibly requires both partners to give consent before an IVF pregnancy can progress - up to the point at which the embryo is implanted.

To read more and to discuss this issue on my blog, click here.

Online Dating Rights
Online Dating Rights opposes the new federal International Marriage Broker Regulation Act, which requires Americans who seek to meet foreigners via the internet to have a criminal background check and an intrusive report about intimate details of one's life BEFORE any communication--the first time in US history that such checks have been required. www.onlinedatingrights.com

Parenting Plan Calendar Software
Shared Ground (R) is an easy-to-use software program designed for divorced parents to track their parenting plan schedules over many years. Do-it-yourself or let us build your approved parenting plan into a multi-year calendar so that you can print, share, or modify the calendar later. Parents, attorneys, arbitrators and mediators can generate equitable parenting plans, which is especially useful for parents seeking fair division of their children's time. FREE ASSISTANCE TO OUR CLIENTS- $49.95 one-time charge, FREE TRIAL & MONEY-BACK GUARANTEE. Click here for more information.
 

SAMSONLAW--Divorce Lawyers for Michigan Men & Fathers
If you're a Michigan man faced with divorce, you need SAMSONLAW on your side--SAMSONLAW defends men.
Smart Advocacy Means Stopping Oppression Now. INeedSamson.com

Anti-Father Attorneys Being Honored by the Government

In the past I've complained that former Los Angeles District Attorney Gil Garcetti, who treated fathers terribly while he was the DA, was later honored by the city of Los Angeles. In my co-authored column Some Progress for California Fathers, but Still a Long Way to Go I wrote:

"In 1998 then-Los Angeles District Attorney Gil Garcetti declared a 'get tough' campaign against so-called 'deadbeat dads,' sending out thousands of summonses for paternity cases. The men were given only 30 days to respond.

"Many of the summonses targeted the wrong men, and many never reached the intended parties. Eighty percent of Garcetti's paternity judgments were made by default, locking the men into 18 years of child support. Many took DNA tests proving that they were not the fathers of the children they now had to take second jobs to support. Others were assigned huge support arrearages by mistake. Many became unable to support their own children. Some of their marriages broke up, and some of the men landed in jail.

"Garcetti created so much chaos and heartache that even diehard feminist attorney Gloria Allred protested. Allred, who has perhaps done more than anybody to promote the phrase and concept of 'deadbeat dads,' called Garcetti's office 'an organization without a heart, without any compassion, and without a sense of priorities...[it's] a system run amok."

"Garcetti later acknowledged that many of the men had been mistakenly targeted but refused to relent, instead blaming the men for not responding within 30 days. 'The law is the law,' he told CBS's Bernard Goldberg."

To this day some of the men Garcetti victimized are still paying child support for children who are not theirs. Yet, incredibly, in 2002 Garcetti was appointed to the Los Angeles City Ethics Commission! "Ethics"?!

Now we have a similar farce. I've written before about the Bridget Marks case. Marks became a poster child for the Feminist Family Law Movement when she lost custody of her twin four-year-old daughters to her ex-boyfriend in 2004 after she claimed that he had molested the girls. Marks successfully took her side of the story to the public via appearances on Larry King Live, PrimeTime Live, The O'Reilly Factor, Dr. Phil and others, as well as through sympathetic "news" articles in the New York Post and the New York Daily News. The record, however, demonstrated that Family Court Judge Arlene Goldberg made the correct decision in the Marks case.

Marks alleged that John Aylsworth, her ex-boyfriend, had sexually abused both daughters during a supervised visitation. In upholding Goldberg's findings, two state Appellate Division, First Department judges, David Friedman and Peter Tom, explained:

"[The trial court's] finding--for which there is ample support in the record--[is] that the mother coached the girls to make false accusations that their father sexually abused them. The Law Guardian and the neutral expert witnesses who testified in this case--the psychiatrist appointed by the court as the independent forensic evaluator, two certified social workers retained by the Law Guardian, and two social workers who supervised the father's visitations during the tendency of the proceedings--all take the view that the accusations are false, and that the children were coached to make them. Even the expert witnesses called by the mother seem to have recognized that the accusations were made in a manner consistent with coaching."

Marks appealed the case, and the state Appellate Division, First Department, in what it described as a "close" call, did transfer custody back to Marks because it felt she could give the children more personal care and attention than Aylsworth, a casino mogul, would be able to. Pro-mother gender bias also drove the Appellate Court's decision.
Nevertheless, all four Appellate justices concluded that Marks had in fact coached her then four-year-old twin girls to believe that they had been sexually molested by their father.

Recently Marks' attorney, Tom Shanahan was named deputy commissioner in the Division on Human Rights for new New York Governor Eliot Spitzer! How a guy who worked hard to defend a woman who coached her little girls to say they'd been molested by their father gets a top job on a "Human Rights" commission is beyond me.

To discuss this issue on my blog, click here.

Fathers' Rights Legal Help
If you need help with divorce, child custody, child support, alimony and visitation issues, The Law Offices of Jeffery M. Leving, Ltd. is one of the only law firms in the country focused almost exclusively on fathers' rights in divorce. Leving did heroic work on the Elian Gonzalez case, helping reunite Elian with his father. He also co-authored Illinois' Joint Custody Law, and was named one of "America's Best Lawyers" by Forbes Radio. Leving is the author of Fathers' Rights: Hard Hitting and Fair Advice for Every Father Involved in a Custody Dispute. Call today for an initial consultation (312) 807-3990 or visit us on the web at www.dadsrights.com.
Has Your Career Been Impacted by Custody Issues?
After empowering people's careers for over 20 years, I was duly initiated into family law just like you--through a 30 month, $520,000 custody suit. I learned that a solid home-based business could be the best option, allowing one to shake the financial shackles while still experiencing a "no limits" career. More than ever, our kids now need a free and available parent. Be there for them...and for yourself. Darrell W. Gurney, www.EntrepreneurFromHome.com

More Debate over 'Deadbeat Dad'/Pizza Campaign

Background: Recently Ohio's Butler County Child Support Enforcement Agency launched a highly-publicized new campaign which puts mug shots of the County's "Most Wanted Deadbeat Parents" on pizza boxes. The idea was the brainchild of Agency Executive Director Cynthia Brown. To learn more about the story, click here.

Three representatives of the fathers' movement have debated Cynthia Brown over the past few weeks:

Brown debated family law attorney Maury Beaulier (top right) on Fox & Friends. To watch, click here.

Dr. Stephen Baskerville (right), president of the American Coalition or Fathers and Children, debated Brown on CNN. Video is not yet available, but the transcript of the debate is below.

I debated Brown on FOX News' nationally-syndicated Morning Show with Mike and Juliet on Tuesday (below right)--to watch, click here.

Transcript of ACFC President Stephen Baskerville debating Cynthia Brown on CNN, 4/1/07

BETTY NGUYEN, CNN ANCHOR: A wanted poster delivered with your pizza, of all things, is happening in a suburb of Cincinnati. Mugshots of parents accused of not paying child support appearing on pizza delivery boxes. A child enforcement worker came up with this idea and pitched it to pizza places in Ohio's Butler County.

While this may sound like a good idea, to many, it does have its critics. One of those critics being Steven Baskerville of the American Coalition for Fathers and Children. There he is. And he joins us from Washington. And from Cincinnati, Ohio, this morning, the woman who came up with this idea, Cynthia Brown. Good morning to you both...

To read more and discuss this issue on my blog, click here.

The Business of Love
50% of 1st marriages fail, the rate of marriage has declined 48% in 40 years, single households now outnumber married households...if there ever was a time for a radical, new approach to marriage, it's NOW. The Business of Love, by Dr. John Curtis, an organizational development consultant and former marriage counselor, is the first book to show how to take the same "best practices" that build successful businesses and apply them to an intimate relationship. Learn more at www.TheBusinessofLove.org.

Help for Michigan Dads
Michigan family law attorney Mindy L. Hitchcock has experience fighting for noncustodial parents against Michigan's abusive FOC. Her holistic approach to divorce gets results for her clients while avoiding the scorched earth approach to law that leaves families emotionally and financially devastated. Lady4Justice.com


Chris Rock Mocks Feminist Idea that White Women Have Been Oppressed Like Black Men (Video)

"How can you compare the suffering of a white women to the suffering of a black man? It's not even close!"--Chris Rock

In this humorous monologue, comedian Chris Rock mocks the feminist idea that white women and black men have been similarly oppressed.

(Note: Unlike most of Rock's material, there is no obscenity on this clip.)

To discuss this issue on my blog, click here.

 

 

New DVD set from Dr. Warren Farrell--The Best Interests of the Child
In this new DVD set from Dr. Warren Farrell, one of the foremost experts on children of divorce, he summarizes over 200 studies, and finds that the research is clear: children do far better with near equal exposure to both parents with minimal conditions. The video can be submitted as evidence, and Dr. Farrell is available to testify as an expert witness. www.BestInterestofChildren.org

Help for Los Angeles/Ventura County Dads
Certified Family Law Specialist Peter M. Walzer was one of the key figures in our successful legislative struggle to preserve the LaMusga move-away decision. As Chair of the State Bar of California Family Law Section Executive Committee, Walzer lobbied the state legislature to improve California laws on child support and child custody. He's an American Academy of Matrimonial Lawyers Fellow who has authored numerous articles on custody issues, business valuation in marital dissolutions and spousal and child support.  www.California-Divorce.com


New Study Lumps Fathers in With Day-Care Centers

"If your mother stayed home with you, you were cared for by your parent. However, if your father stayed home with you, according to the NIH study, you are the product of "child care."

Good article from Neil Chethik on a recent child care study:

Fathers shouldn't be lumped in with day-care centers
By Neil Chethik
Lexington Herald-Leader, 4/9/07

The federal government made a splash recently with its newest study of American children who attend day care at an early age. The research showed that day-care kids are more argumentative in grade school but have better vocabularies than most of their classmates.

Just as important was what didn't make the headlines. In the fine print of the study --funded by the U.S. government's National Institutes of Health -- was the definition of "child care" that the study adopted. Lumped together with care provided by preschools and day-care centers was care provided by the child's father.

That's right. If your mother stayed home with you, you were cared for by your parent. However, if your father stayed home with you, according to the NIH study, you are the product of "child care."

To read more and discuss this issue on my blog, click here.

Help for Colorado Dads
As someone who has personally experienced the heartbreak of divorce and family breakup, Brett W. Martin, Esq. works to advance the interests and concerns of fathers in domestic and family law litigation. Personal attention is given to clients to help them through a very difficult time in their lives. www.brettwmartin.com

Is being a Disneyland Dad taking its toll?  Does your 'career' get in the way of seeing your kids?  
Having dealt with the family law system for over two decades, I understand the frustration of working long hours at a job while dealing with the unfair rules that our system imposes on dads and their kids. I finally found a life-changing income opportunity that allows me the time and money freedom to be there for my kids on my terms. If you would like to learn more about how to take back control and live your life without limits, visit liberatedintexas.com.


Could You Ever Find a Clearer Example of the Gender Double-Standard?

A story from Germany:

"Desperate fathers are being urged to drop their unwanted babies through hatches at hospitals in Germany in an effort to halt a spate of infanticides that has shocked the country.

"At least 23 babies have been killed so far this year, many of them beaten to death or strangled by their fathers before being dumped on wasteland and in dustbins.

"Police investigating the murders are at a loss to explain the sudden surge in such cases, which have involved fathers of all ages all over the country."

Of course this isn't real--nobody would call fathers who beat or strangle their children "desperate." Such kindness and sensitivity is reserved for mothers and mothers only. From 'Baby-Drops' Introduced in Germany as Infanticide Cases Spike (The Times, 3/27/07):

"Desperate mothers are being urged to drop their unwanted babies through hatches at hospitals in Germany in an effort to halt a spate of infanticides that has shocked the country.

"At least 23 babies have been killed so far this year, many of them beaten to death or strangled by their mothers before being dumped on wasteland and in dustbins.

"Police investigating the murders are at a loss to explain the sudden surge in such cases, which have involved mothers of all ages all over the country."

German authorities shouldn't be wringing their hands over "desperate" mothers--they should be organizing manhunts--pardon me, womanhunts--for these murderesses, just as they would (and should) when a father murders his child.

Postscript: On my blog someone wrote "You come across as somebody who wants to punish mothers, rather than someone who cares about the welfare of babies." I responded:

"I want to punish parents who kill their children, not 'mothers.' But on one level you're right, because if we don't allow women to dump their unwanted babies, they might kill them, so in a sense the Safe Haven laws, etc., are necessary. But it really rubs me the wrong way when we refer to mothers (or fathers) who kill their children as 'desperate,' or as victims."

To discuss this issue on my blog, click here.

Are You the Target of Parental Alienation?
Parental alienation cases are among the most difficult and complicated in family law. J. Michael Bone, Ph.D., is an expert on parental alienation. If you're a target parent, he can help you get back into your children's lives. Bone has worked as a custody evaluator and as a therapist and knows how to help the court find the truth. His services are available throughout the U.S. Dr. Bone can be reached by phone at (407) 645-0662 or by email by clicking here. www.jmbconsulting.org

If You're Dealing with False Accusations or Custody Battles, You're Probably Dealing With...
Alcohol and other-drug addiction--Doug Thorburn's AddictionReport E-newsletter explains it all. O.J., Lindsay Lohan, Mel Gibson are addicts--your ex-spouse may be as well. Subscribe now and learn how to avoid being caught up in addicts' mind games. To subscribe, click here. www.AddictionReport.com


ABC's 'A Wife Behind Bars'

Matt from www.mensactivism.org has some interesting comments on the death of Marine Todd Sommer. Matt writes:

"[ABC] portrays the wife of dead Marine Todd Sommer as a victim of circumstance and faulty lab work. Plenty of up-closes with her crying as she sat behind a desk in jail. In short: the usual predictable stuff.

"Right after her husband is dead from arsenic poisoning, she rushes to collect his insurance money, buys herself breast implants, parties at strip clubs and bars like a Girls Gone Wild'er, sleeps around like there is no tomorrow, and ABC has the nerve portray her as having a 'unique way of processing her grief' and 'trouble adjusting,' and certainly not guilty of murdering him."

Matt's post is here. I actually don't agree with Matt that the ABC coverage was unfair--I thought it was more or less balanced.

To discuss this issue on my blog, click here.

Use Evidence to Win Your Case
Judges hear "he said/she said" all day long. If your ex-spouse is an abusive or neglectful parent, has employed false allegations or is lying to the court, you need evidence to win your case. Private investigator Guy White consults on divorce cases nationwide and knows how to collect the evidence you need to win your case. Contact him at piguywhite@aol.com or (480) 994-4002. www.guypi.com

How to Win Shared Custody
If you are an active, engaged, committed, dedicated, loving parent facing a divorce, family law attorney Nicholas Palermo's The Ten Essential Elements to Winning Joint Shared Physical and Legal Custody can help you protect your relationship with your children. www.TenEssentialElements.com


I Enjoy Watching Birkhead Gloat a Little--Here's the Video

After what Larry Birkhead has been through, he deserves to gloat a little. See the video here.

From the Associated Press' "Birkhead: 'I Told You So'--DNA Confirms Larry Birkhead Is the Father of Anna Nicole Smith's Daughter":

"NASSAU, April 10, 2007 -- Anna Nicole Smith's former boyfriend Larry Birkhead said Tuesday that DNA tests have proven he is the father of her infant daughter.

"Birkhead emerged from a closed court hearing to announce the results. Smith's companion, Howard K. Stern, has been caring for the girl, Dannielynn, who could inherit a fortune in the wake of her mother's February death.

"After the hearing, Stern said he would not fight for custody. An expert in genetic evidence said the DNA analysis has proven Birkhead is Dannielynn's father.

"Dr. Michael Baird, who analyzed the results of a March 21 DNA test, announced the results outside the court.

"'Essentially, he's the biological father,' Baird said.

"A jubilant Birkhead said, 'My baby's going to be coming home pretty soon.'"

As I explained in my co-authored column Anna Nicole Dispute Shows System's Flaws (Chicago Sun-Times, 3/10/07), I think it's disgraceful the way Birkhead was jerked around and his relationship with his baby daughter stymied. 

To discuss this issue on my blog, click here.

Do You Want Shared Custody of Your Kids?
Do you want shared custody of your kids? Are your kids being alienated from you? Karen Wagner, M.Ed., a nationally known expert on children of divorce, believes your children want you in their lives, and she can help you make it happen. Contact Wagner Consulting Services at 678-480-1550 or at HappyChildren@comcast.net. Services available throughout the US. www.wagnerconsultingservices.com

Help for North Carolina Dads
Steve Monks and the Monks Law Firm helps North Carolina dads with all their family law needs, from preparation of a simple separation agreement to a full-blown custody case. The Monks Law Firm offers a guaranteed fixed-rate fee upon evaluation of your case--without the burden of hourly rates hanging over your head, you can concentrate on solving your legal problems instead of worrying about the bill. www.monkslawnc.com


Authors of Legalizing Misandry to Speak on 'Coming of Age as a Villain' at Men's Equality Congress

Background: Boys and the Boy Crisis, the Third National Men's Equality Congress, will be held July 13-14 in Washington D.C. The speakers list is great--perhaps the best I've ever seen at a conference. Speakers include: Matt O'Connor, leader of the English fathers' group Fathers 4 Justice; Christina Hoff Sommers--author of Who Stole Feminism?; Warren Farrell; author of Father & Child Reunion; and Stephen Baskerville, president of the American Coalition for Fathers and Children. I will also be speaking.

There will also be three 2+ hour pre-conference workshops, one conducted by Matt O'Connor, one by Warren Farrell, and one by myself. The workshops will start Friday morning and conclude prior the conference opening that evening. To sign up for 'early bird' prices for these workshops and/or to register for the conference, click here.

One of the presentations I'm looking forward to is from Paul Nathanson and Katherine Young, co-authors of Spreading Misandry: The Teaching of Contempt for Men in Popular Culture and Legalizing Misandry: From Public Shame to Systemic Discrimination Against Men. Their presentation is called "Coming of Age as a Villain: What Young Men Need to Know in a Misandric World." Here's a summary of what they will be discussing:

"We will begin by discussing coming-of-age as a cultural process that in other times and places fostered the transformation of boys into men. What happens in a society that provides not only fails to acknowledge the entry into manhood but also--and this is even more important--refuses to provide an acceptable view of manhood in the first place? The social-scientific evidence looks very grim, most obviously (but not only) the statistics on suicide and dropping out of school.

"What's going on? These are symptoms, we suggest, of a much deeper problem. By and large, people are either unaware of this problem or unwilling to do something about it. In that sense, it is analogous to what Betty Friedan called women's 'disease with no name.' But it has a name now: misandry."

To sign up for 'early bird' prices for these workshops and/or to register for the conference, click here. See you there.

To discuss this issue on my blog, click here.
 

Help for Los Angeles/Orange County Dads--Because They're Your Kids, Too
If you're a dad facing a divorce or separation and you need quality legal representation in Los Angeles or Orange County, the Law Office of David Stone can help. Remember, they're your kids, too. www.help4dad.com

Help for Georgia Dads
Georgia attorney Edwin M. Saginar has 36 years of experience in family law and criminal defense, including domestic violence. He has seen many spouses falsely accuse their significant others of family violence, and knows how to defend your rights. www.edwinsaginar.com


Imagine That--Davis High School Students Tell Paper They Don't Feel Safe Around Feminist Heroine Sadia Loeliger

Background: As part of our successful 2005 campaign against PBS's anti-father film Breaking the Silence: Children's Stories, we publicly revealed extensive documentation, court findings, records and testimony that indicate that Sadia Loeliger--portrayed as a heroic mom in the film--abused children under her care. A Tulare County Juvenile Court concluded in August of 1998 that Sadia Loeliger had committed multiple acts of child abuse, and adjudged both her daughters as dependents of the Juvenile Court.

Sadia Loeliger and her severely alienated 16 year-old daughter Fatima were key figures in the feminist film, which purported to detail an alleged crisis of fit mothers losing custody of their children to violent husbands in divorce. In the film, Sadia is portrayed as the victim of her ex-husband Dr. Scott Loeliger and anti-mother bias in family courts .

A year later, in part because of our work, Connecticut Public Television and Tatge-Lasseur Productions, the film's co-producers, were forced to publicly apologize to Dr. Scott Loeliger for the film's misleading portrayal of the family court case involving himself, his daughter Fatima and his ex-wife Sadia. To learn more about the Loeliger case, click here. To learn more about our PBS campaign, click here.

From the mouths of babes...

The Davis Enterprise recently ran a news story about a controversy at the school over alleged racism in the school's hiring policies. Sadia Loeliger, who is also known as Sadiya Alilire, has gotten involved in the controversy.

What's interesting is that the article mentions in passing that "Some of the students objected to Alilire's plans to attend the conference, in turn, saying they felt unsafe around her." In fact, the paper reports that students went as far as asking Davis schools Superintendent Richard Whitmore to prevent her from attending.

Children feeling unsafe around this feminist heroine? Imagine that...

BSU president to skip state conference

Beth Curda Enterprise staff writer

March 23, 2007

The family of Davis High School senior Fatima Loeliger announced today she would not attend this weekend's conference with the school's Black Student Union. The 17-year-old president of the student organization and her mother and stepfather believed her safety would be a concern during the school group's trip to the United Black Student Union of California convention, an annual statewide gathering in Burbank this year.

They announced in a written statement today that adult community activists with whom Loeliger has been at odds recently were authorized late this week by the school district to attend the trip. Loeliger this month has been at the heart of an internal BSU feud that has extended to include others in the Davis African-American community. The announcement about the authorizations is not true, said Ginni Davis, associate superintendent for educational services for the school district.

In trying to avoid canceling the students' trip in recent weeks, the district worked with the competing sides in the issue and, in the end, had authorized Loeliger's mother, another couple with a child in the organization, two vice principals and another school district representative to attend, either as chaperones or just in parental roles. None of the adults authorized to go are those with whom Loeliger has been at odds, Davis said. She did not know this morning whether they had attended on their own. Neither Loeliger nor her mother, Sadiya Alilire, went with the group today.

Conflicts among students, parents and community activists arose during and following a March 1 BSU meeting and were one driving force behind a march Wednesday from the high school to the school district administrative offices. Loeliger's mother had planned to attend the conference out of concern for her daughter's safety. Alilire's concern followed the contentious meeting and what she considers inappropriate participation by parents and adult activists. Some of the students objected to Alilire's plans to attend the conference, in turn, saying they felt unsafe around her. During their march and meeting with interim Davis schools Superintendent Richard Whitmore on Wednesday, they asked him to change the arrangement that allowed Alilire to attend.

To discuss this issue on my blog, click here.

How to Stop a Dirty Divorce
Many fathers are very naive when they walk into family court, and the results can be disastrous. Family Law Attorney A.J. Comparetto's Ultimate Guide to Stopping a Dirty Divorce teaches you the Dirty Divorce tricks before they are played on you. It's a series of cassettes and videos which teaches you what judges really want to hear from you in court, how to keep your words from being twisted by attorneys, and how to keep your kids from being caught in the middle. www.divorceproblems.com

Child Custody A to Z
Private investigator Guy White's Child Custody A to Z tells you how child custody cases are won and lost. White provides an insider's perspective on how to choose an attorney, impeach court experts, gather evidence, expose personality disorders and investigate your case. Guy White identifies how you should act, think, protect, and live your child custody case. To buy Child Custody A to Z, click here.


Another Blow to the Lazy Husband Myth

One of the most common and pernicious anti-male myths in popular culture is the myth of the lazy husband. As I've noted before, research shows that when both work outside the home and inside the home are properly considered, it is clear that men do at least as much as women.

The new article Dads increase time with children, housework (Washington Post, 4/6/07) discusses a University of Maryland study that shows that the total workloads of married mothers and fathers -- when paid work is added to child care and housework -- is roughly equal, at 65 hours a week for mothers and 64 hours for fathers.

The article goes into the obligatory "men used to not do enough but now they're getting better" routine, but I don't see any evidence in the article to show that men were ever doing less overall than women. Yes, in the past men did less childcare and housework, but women did less market labor, too. And much research shows that even in the pre-feminist era men worked as many hours overall as women did, and this doesn't even account for the physically demanding, dangerous work that so many men did when America had a mostly industrial economy.

To learn more about men, women and work, see my co-authored column Are American Husbands Slackers? (Tallahassee Democrat, 3/22/06). Warren Farrell also has an excellent section on this in his 1999 book Women Can't Hear What Men Don't Say.


Dads increase time with children, housework

Washington Post, 4/6/07

It was a Saturday, and Roberto Clark was out with his 6-year-old daughter and 7-year-old twin sons. They hit the mall to pick up baseball caps and were headed to Dairy Queen for ice cream. Clark figured they would be out of the house half a day, a time to reconnect after a long week of work and school.

"The only way to really understand their lives is to hang out with them, talk with them, play with them," said Clark, a 36-year-old businessman from Frederick County, Md., who said he does not remember such "Daddy Time" from his own childhood, possibly because fathers were more often around the house.

In what is surely a sign of modern life, recent research shows that over the past four decades, fathers like Clark have nearly tripled the hours they spend focused on their children. They still lag behind American mothers, who put in about twice as many hours directly involved with their children and doing housework. But, as researcher Suzanne M. Bianchi put it, today's fathers "do a lot more than their fathers did."

A comprehensive study of "time diaries" by researchers from the University of Maryland shows that fathers have increased their child-care work from 2.5 hours a week in 1965 to seven hours a week in 2003. There is a similar trend with housework: Dads did 4.4 hours a week in 1965 and 9.6 hours a week in 2003. Perhaps even more striking, the total workloads of married mothers and fathers -- when paid work is added to child care and housework -- is roughly equal, at 65 hours a week for mothers and 64 hours for fathers.

"It's not the case that men are slugs," said William Doherty, a family studies professor at the University of Minnesota who has done several studies on fatherhood. "It's a new generation of fathers, and they are internalizing some of the very high expectations that mothers have."

To read more and to discuss this issue on my blog, click here.
 

Expose False Allegations with Technology
Don't let the anti-male bias in criminal law victimize you. If you could be falsely accused by an angry woman, be prepared! Use technology to expose the real aggressor. DontMakeHerMad.com

Steven Carlson's How to Win Child Custody
Are you contemplating divorce or separation but are unsure about how child custody will be determined or what you can expect from attorneys and the family court system? Knowing these things can help you win custody. Steven Carlson is known nationally as The Custody Coach, and has helped thousands of parents with child custody and custody evaluation. He is the author of "How to Win Child Custody" and the founder of Child Custody Coach in Orange County, California. Don't get caught unprepared, download your copy of "How to Win Child Custody" today.


The Link Between Abortion and Domestic Violence

According to Abortion linked to domestic violence, study finds (The Age [Australia], 4/7/07):

"The long-lasting impact of violent relationships on women has been illustrated in research showing that young women abused by their partners are more than twice as likely to have an abortion as those who have not.

"The data analysis, by La Trobe University researchers Angela Taft and Lyndsey Watson, found that partner violence is the most powerful factor in whether a young woman decides to terminate an unwanted pregnancy."

The implication is that the women are having abortions because their abusive male partners are forcing/coercing them to do so. Recently there has been a legislative push by right-to-life groups to punish men who could be perceived as having pressured or manipulated their girlfriends or ex-girlfriends into having abortions. I discussed the U.S.'s first legislation on this--the Coercive Abortion Prevention Act--in my co-authored column Coercive Abortion Prevention Act Assumes Male Guilt, Opens Door to Unfair Prosecutions (Detroit News, 11/30/06).

I think there is some validity to the view that some women are having abortions because their abusive male partners are forcing/coercing them to do so, but there are other explanations, too. These include:

1) The women could be more likely to have an abortion because they quite sensibly don't want to have a child with a violent man.

2) The women could be more likely to have an abortion because the relationship is falling apart or is on the rocks, as indicated by the man's violence.

3) Since male abusers tend to come from the lower end of the economic spectrum, the woman might be more likely to have an abortion because of poverty, as the study also found.

I share society's horror of violence against pregnant women, but I oppose the extreme violation of civil liberties and assumptions of male perfidy that defined Michigan's CAPA. I explain this below.

Coercive Abortion Prevention Act Assumes Male Guilt, Opens Door to Unfair
Prosecutions

By Jeffery M. Leving and Glenn Sacks

Detroit News, 11/30/06

Bob and Jane live together and, like many young couples, they sometimes argue. There never seems to be enough money, and while they both want to go to college, neither has yet been able to do so. Jane recently discovered that she is pregnant.

Jane is ambivalent about the pregnancy, and her friends think she should terminate it--she's too young, and Bob isn't very stable. Bob would like to be a father someday, but not now--he can't pay their bills and wants a better career.

One day Bob and Jane argue over some things Jane bought with their credit card, and Bob tells Jane he doesn't want to pay their bills anymore. He says he's tired of arguing with her, doesn't want her to have the baby, and wants to move out for a while and think things over.

Under a bill recently passed by the Michigan House of Representatives, Bob could go to jail.

To read more and to discuss this issue on my blog, click here.

Help for Boston Dads
Boston family law attorney Nick Palermo is a shared custody advocate who believes that divorced dads are parents, not visitors. The Law Offices of Nicholas Palermo is a dedicated and committed trial law firm which has worked to make shared custody for all fit parents the law of the land. LAW OFFICES OF NICHOLAS PALERMO

Los Angeles Dads--Free Legal Consultation on Your Case
If you are involved in a divorce, domestic violence, paternity, child custody or support case in the greater Los Angeles area, call Stephen A. Gershman to schedule your FREE initial one hour consultation at (888) 295-1756 or (818) 990-6505. Gershman is certified as a Specialist in Family Law by the Board of Legal Specialization of the State Bar of California. He is an experienced attorney, over 25 years, who will competently and aggressively defend you against unjust domestic violence restraining orders or unfair financial obligations. When Parental Alienation or custody is an issue, he will help you protect your relationship with your kids. www.losangelesfamilylawyer.com


Progress--the NY Times Understands that 'Absent' Minority Fathers Sometimes Were Driven from Their Children's Lives

The New York Times isn't normally terribly prescient when it comes to gender issues and fathers' issues, but Times reporter Leslie Kaufman gets it right in her new article In Custody Fights, a Hurdle for the Poor (4/8/07). Kaufman writes:

"Custody battles are rarely gentle affairs, but if you are poor, such fights can carry an added frustration: waiting months to get a court-approved visit with your own child.

"In cases involving allegations of domestic violence, which are increasing, or other issues, such as drug abuse and long absenteeism, judges often require that child's visits with the noncustodial parent take place only in the presence of a professional, like a social worker.

"But when judges order supervised visitation, neither the court nor other government agencies pay for the service, a growing problem in New York City and across the nation.

"Because he cannot afford to pay for supervised visitation, which routinely costs $100 an hour, Juan Manuel Fernandez, 51, of Washington Heights, said, he has not seen his two daughters, ages 6 and 11, since last October. A year ago, he said, his wife walked out, moved the girls to New Jersey, and told the court he was threatening her. He denies the accusation, but the judge in his case ruled that supervision was necessary. So now he is waiting for free supervision through a nonprofit agency, which can take months.

"'It's very hard to have to wait to see your own kids,' Mr. Fernandez said in Spanish, through a translator.

"'Imagine it, they're just little girls. I felt like crying when I had to leave them,' he said, especially because he knew it could be a long time before he could see them.

"In supervised visitations, a third party oversees the handoff of children between parents and then monitors the interaction. The concept is not new, and sometimes the supervision can be done by a member of one of the couple's families. Still, more judges think it is safer to order professional supervision, particularly in cases involving domestic violence or sexual abuse, drug use, mental illness, a history of criminal activity or jail time, or simply longtime absenteeism.

"When these factors turn up in custody fights, for low-income couples, the ensuing costs for supervised visits can be insurmountable.

"The only option for most of those families is to get in line for free supervision through a nonprofit agency. But only a handful of groups provide the free service, and they say because of financing pressures, the wait can often reach six months."

Note that in the Fernandez case, while we don't know whether he committed abuse or is the victim of  a false accusation, there appears to have been no real adjudication of the abuse claims. Certainly there was no conviction or finding at the clear and convincing evidence standard. It sounds like it was he said/she said and the judge decided to be on the safe side and ordered supervised visitation, effectively barring Fernandez from his kids' lives.

To read more and to discuss this issue on my blog, click here.

Legal Help for Fathers in New Jersey
If you're a New Jersey father facing a divorce or separation, the law firm of Pitman, Pitman, Mindas, Grossman & Lee can help. PitmanLaw.com

Without Honor
Has the family court system failed you? Without Honor is the true expose of one man's journey in the Rancho Cucamonga, California Family Law court system. It chronicles the destruction of a man's life at the hands of unethical attorneys and judges, who carry out their operations under the guise of equitable, established law and the facade of respectability. Order Without Honor by clicking here.


The Myth that Child Support Enforcement 'Collects $4.10 for Every Federal Dollar Spent'

One of the popular myths employed to justify huge, wasteful expenditures for child support enforcement (and to justify child support enforcement abuses) is the myth that "Child Support Enforcement 'Collects $4.10 for Every Federal Dollar Spent.'

The stat apparently comes from the Congressional Budget Office, and has been repeated ad infinitum, including in the news story Child-support services in peril (Denver Post, 4/6/07). As usual, the child support collection industry is whining that the feds don't lavish them with enough money to waste.

In my co-authored column Federal Child Support Enforcement Cuts Will Hurt Bureaucrats, not Children (Las Vegas Review-Journal and others, 12/17/05), I explained:

"According to the Congressional Budget Office, this will lead to $24 billion in child support going uncollected over the next 10 years. Texas Attorney General Greg Abbott and Los Angeles County Child Support Services Department Director Philip Browning are warning that the cuts will mean a drastic reduction in the amount of child support collected. A  bipartisan group of senators has penned a letter opposing the cuts, explaining that 'in 2004, more than $4 was collected in support for every dollar invested in the program.' All of these claims, however, are based on false assumptions and misleading data.

"It is true that federal figures show that over $20 billion in child support is collected nationwide yearly, and that only $5 billion is spent on enforcement. However, the vast majority of the funds collected are not done through enforcement tactics--they're simply the payments already being made by law-abiding noncustodial parents. These payments will continue to be made regardless of the cuts. The myth that child support enforcement is a bargain was created by incorrectly counterposing total collections with expenditures on enforcement.

"In reality, much if not most child support enforcement funds are frittered away in misguided attempts to collect artificially inflated paper arrearages from low-income men who couldn't possibly pay them. Read the rest of this entry »

To read more and to discuss this issue on my blog, click here.
 

Help for Maryland Fathers
Family law attorney Dawn Elaine Bowie works to protect parents' relationships with their children and reduce